Kristen RidleyA car accident can upend your life in seconds.
Between mounting medical bills, lost wages, and New York’s complex no-fault system, knowing which attorney to call matters more than most people realize. The right lawyer can be the difference between a lowball settlement and a recovery that genuinely makes you whole.
This editorial guide profiles eight of the most recommended and highest-rated car accident attorneys serving Westchester County. We evaluated firms based on Google ratings, peer-reviewed recognitions, documented case results, and local presence.
How We Evaluated Westchester County’s Top-Reviewed Car Accident Lawyers
Our methodology weighted six factors: Google review ratings and volume, third-party legal recognitions, published verdicts and settlements, physical presence in Westchester, depth of client testimonials, and total years of courtroom experience.
We prioritized firms with genuine Westchester ties over national advertising firms with no local footprint. We also included a few larger regional practices that have demonstrated meaningful results for Westchester clients.
The Most Recommended Car Accident Lawyers Serving Westchester County
#1 Worby Vecchio Edelman, LLP
Worby Vecchio Edelman is the most decorated personal injury firm in Westchester County by traditional legal industry metrics. Senior partner David Worby has held a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating for over 30 consecutive years.
He has been selected to Super Lawyers every year since 2007 and was named Best Lawyers’ “Lawyer of the Year” in 2020 for personal injury litigation in White Plains. The Westchester County Board of Legislators even declared a “David Worby Day” in his honor.
The firm served as co-lead counsel for the 9/11 World Trade Center Workers class action, representing more than 8,000 plaintiffs. It has recovered over $1 billion total throughout its history.
| Lead Attorneys | David E. Worby; Richard S. Vecchio; Michael R. Edelman |
| Office | 81 Main St, Suite 306, White Plains, NY 10601 |
| Phone | (914) 686-3700 |
| Website | wvelaw.com |
| Founded | 1995 |
| Recognitions | Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent 30+ consecutive years; David Worby: Super Lawyers 2007–2024, Best Lawyers 2006–2026, “Lawyer of the Year” 2020, National Trial Lawyers Top 100 (2026); Richard Vecchio: Super Lawyers since 2012, past President Westchester County Bar Association; U.S. News Best PI Law Firms (2023) |
| Notable Results | $1 billion+ total recovered; $8.78M (auto accident hospital negligence); $8M (quadriplegia from ER infection); $5.1M (passenger head injury); $5.05M (unsafe auto design); $4.25M (overturned truck collision); $3M (car/truck collision) |
| Unique Differentiators | Co-lead counsel for 9/11 WTC Workers class action; founded the David E. Worby Course in Advanced Trial Practice at Villanova Law School; media appearances on CBS, NBC, ABC, Fox, CNN, Court TV |
| Languages | English, Spanish |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, “You don’t pay unless we help you collect” |
#2 Jeffrey Weiskopf, P.C.
Jeffrey Weiskopf, P.C. earns the #2 spot for a rare combination of credentials. The firm holds a perfect 5.0-star Google rating from over 50 client reviews.
Weiskopf is one of the few Westchester personal injury attorneys who serves as an adjunct professor of law at Cardozo School of Law, where he has taught since 2018. Before founding his Ossining firm, he served as a Senior Court Attorney to a Manhattan judge.
The firm has recovered more than $20 million for injured clients. In December 2025, a $2.021 million jury verdict Weiskopf won was nominated for TopVerdict.com’s Top 100 Verdicts in New York for 2025.
What clients consistently emphasize is that Weiskopf personally handles every case from intake to resolution. Nothing is delegated to junior associates.
| Lead Attorney | Jeffrey M. Weiskopf, Esq. |
| Office | 30 State St, Suite 2B, Ossining, NY 10562 |
| Phone | (914) 350-5175 (24/7) |
| Website | weiskopflaw.com |
| Google Rating | 5.0 stars / 50+ reviews |
| Years in Practice | ~20 years |
| Education | J.D., Cardozo School of Law (2006); B.A., University of Michigan (2002) |
| Bar Admissions | NY State; S.D.N.Y., E.D.N.Y., N.D.N.Y.; admitted pro hac vice in Florida |
| Notable Results | $3.25M (medical malpractice); $2.021M verdict (premises liability, 2025, nominated for NY Top 100); $1.8M (failure to diagnose lung cancer); $1.25M (product liability); $995K (pedestrian/auto); $950K (failure to diagnose glaucoma) |
| Recognitions | TopVerdict Top 100 Verdict Nominee (2025); ranked #1 PI Lawyer in Westchester County by IsThatLegal.org; TrustAnalytica Top Pick |
| Unique Differentiators | Adjunct Professor of Law at Cardozo School of Law; former Senior Court Attorney to Hon. Tanya R. Kennedy; personally handles every case; strong medical malpractice capability |
| Practice Areas | Car accidents, truck/motorcycle/bicycle/pedestrian accidents, construction accidents, slip and falls, medical malpractice, wrongful death, product liability, Uber accidents, hit and run |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, no fee unless they win; free consultation |
#3 Lever & Ecker, PLLC
Lever & Ecker has built the largest Google review presence of any personal injury firm headquartered in Westchester County. The White Plains firm maintains approximately 200+ reviews with a perfect 5.0-star average.
Founded in 1990, the firm makes a deliberate choice that distinguishes it from high-volume settlement mills. Each attorney handles only 25 to 30 active cases at a time.
The firm reports more than $12 million in top verdicts and a 99% case success rate. Notable results include a $12 million wrongful death recovery for a pedestrian struck by a bus and a $1.25 million rear-end auto settlement at full policy limits.
| Lead Attorneys | David B. Lever; Daniel G. Ecker; Adam C. Weiss |
| Office | 120 Bloomingdale Rd, Suite 401, White Plains, NY 10605 |
| Phone | (914) 288-9191 |
| Website | leverecker.com |
| Google Rating | 5.0 stars / ~200+ reviews |
| Founded | 1990 |
| Recognitions | David Lever: Super Lawyers 2020–2024; Adam Weiss: Super Lawyers Rising Star 2020–2025, National Trial Lawyers Top 40 Under 40, Hudson Valley Top Lawyer 2021–2025; Daniel Ecker: Co-chaired NYSBA Trial Lawyers Section Fall Meeting |
| Notable Results | $12M (pedestrian/wrongful death); $12.2M verdict (construction); $8.8M (parking garage trip and fall); $3.48M (pedestrian knockdown); $1.25M (rear-end auto, full policy limits); $755K verdict (auto neck injuries) |
| Unique Differentiators | Caseload deliberately capped at 25–30 per attorney; founding partner survived motorcycle accident as teen; never represented insurance companies |
| Languages | English, Spanish |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, no win, no fee; available 24/7 |
#4 Block O’Toole & Murphy, LLP
Block O’Toole & Murphy is technically NYC-based, but its track record in Westchester County is too significant to leave off this list. The firm has secured more million-dollar-plus results than any other personal injury firm in New York since 2012.
It holds a U.S. News & World Report Tier 1 ranking for plaintiffs’ personal injury litigation. Founding partner Jeffrey Block was named Best Lawyers’ “Lawyer of the Year” for NYC personal injury litigation in 2023.
For Westchester car accident victims, the results are remarkable. They include a $22.5 million settlement for a head-on collision and a $20.18 million verdict for another head-on collision on an icy Westchester road.
| Lead Attorneys | Jeffrey A. Block; Daniel P. O’Toole; Stephen J. Murphy |
| Office | 1 Penn Plaza, Suite 4850, New York, NY 10119 |
| Phone | (212) 736-5300 |
| Website | blockotoole.com |
| Google Rating | ~4.8 stars / 111+ reviews |
| Founded | 1989 |
| Recognitions | U.S. News Tier 1 (PI Litigation, Plaintiffs, NYC metro); Jeffrey Block: Best Lawyers since 2014, “Lawyer of the Year” 2023, Super Lawyers since 2008, Top 100 Trial Lawyers; 300+ results exceeding $1M; Excellence in Advocacy Award (2025) |
| Westchester-Specific Results | $22.5M (head-on collision, 26 surgeries); $20.18M verdict (head-on collision, icy road); $4.25M (rear-end, Bedford); $3M (landscaper/tractor trailer); $1.85M (icy driveway slip); $1.5M (Westchester woman, car accident) |
| Unique Differentiators | Most $1M+ PI results of any NY firm since 2012; partner-driven boutique model; trial-first philosophy |
| Languages | English, Spanish, Russian, Polish |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, free consultation |
#5 Finkelstein & Partners, LLP
Finkelstein & Partners is the only large regional personal injury firm with an actual physical office in Westchester County, located in White Plains. The firm was founded in 1959 and now fields more than 85 attorneys across 19 offices.
Managing partner Andrew Finkelstein currently serves as President of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association. He has been named to the National Trial Lawyers’ Top 50 Most Influential list for 11 consecutive years.
The firm has recovered more than $3 billion for clients since its founding. Notable results include a $50 million confidential settlement and a $31 million jury verdict for a rear-end collision by a box truck.
| Lead Attorney | Andrew G. Finkelstein, Managing Partner |
| Westchester Office | One North Broadway, Suite 900, White Plains, NY 10601 |
| Phone | (914) 761-2875 |
| Website | lawampm.com |
| Google Rating | ~5.0 stars / ~40 reviews (White Plains) |
| Founded | 1959 |
| Recognitions | Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent (2025); 58th President of NYSTLA; National Trial Lawyers Top 50 Most Influential (11 consecutive years); NYT bestselling author; Harvard Law School lecturer |
| Notable Results | $50M confidential settlement; $31M jury verdict (rear-end by box truck); $13.5M (teenage MVA passenger); $8.9M (rear-end collision); $6.8M (truck driver tailgating); $5.9M (motorcycle); $5.7M (school bus wrongful death) |
| Unique Differentiators | Only large firm with actual Westchester office; 85+ attorneys across 19 offices; chairs national MDL steering committees |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, no upfront costs |
#6 Law Offices of Michael H. Joseph, PLLC
The Law Offices of Michael H. Joseph stands out as one of the only trilingual personal injury firms serving Westchester County. Its attorneys are fluent in English, Spanish, and Portuguese.
Michael Joseph holds an Avvo 10/10 “Superb” rating. He has earned recognition from Super Lawyers, the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, and the National Trial Lawyers Top 100.
What distinguishes this firm is its dual practice in personal injury and civil rights litigation. That combination signals comfort with aggressive, trial-ready advocacy.
| Lead Attorneys | Michael H. Joseph; Clifford S. Nelson; John V. Tait |
| Offices | 203 East Post Rd, White Plains, NY 10601; 18 West 33rd St, Suite 400, New York, NY 10001 |
| Phone | (914) 354-3809 |
| Website | newyorktriallawyers.org |
| Avvo Rating | 10/10 “Superb” |
| Founded | ~1999 |
| Recognitions | Avvo 10/10 Superb; Avvo Client’s Choice (2021); Super Lawyers; Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum; National Trial Lawyers Top 100; National Association of Distinguished Counsel; Martindale-Hubbell Client Champion (Gold) |
| Notable Results | $1.013M jury verdict (construction scaffolding); $900K (window washer fall); $848K (defective pipe scaffold); $750K jury verdict (rear-end by garbage truck, Westchester Supreme Court) |
| Unique Differentiators | Trilingual practice; civil rights / police misconduct practice alongside PI; cases featured in major NY media outlets |
| Languages | English, Spanish, Portuguese |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, free consultation |
#7 Peter DeFilippis & Associates
Based in Ardsley in the heart of Westchester County, Peter DeFilippis & Associates is a true local firm. Peter DeFilippis has earned Super Lawyers recognition every year since 2010.
He holds a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent peer rating and has been inducted into the NY Law Journal’s Verdicts & Settlements Hall of Fame. With 35+ years of courtroom experience, DeFilippis brings deep local knowledge of Westchester courts.
| Lead Attorney | Peter DeFilippis |
| Office | Ardsley, NY (also Manhattan) |
| Phone | (914) 478-7777 |
| Website | legalrightsadvice.com |
| Years in Practice | 35+ years |
| Recognitions | Super Lawyers every year since 2010 (14+ consecutive years); National Trial Lawyers Top 100 Civil Plaintiff; Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent; Client Distinction Award; NY Law Journal Verdicts & Settlements Hall of Fame |
| Unique Differentiators | Ardsley-based, genuine Westchester local; Verdicts & Settlements Hall of Fame inductee; firm-stated 99% success rate |
| Practice Areas | Car accidents, medical malpractice, slip and fall, premises liability, wrongful death |
| Fee Structure | Contingency (one-third of recovery) |
#8 Hausman & Pendzick
Hausman & Pendzick is a Harrison-based firm with deep Westchester roots. Lead trial counsel Jay Hausman has earned Super Lawyers recognition for six consecutive years (2020 to 2025).
The firm pairs Hausman’s trial experience with managing partner Elizabeth Pendzick’s dedicated motion and appellate practice. Clients consistently appreciate the direct attorney access at this firm.
| Lead Attorneys | Jay S. Hausman; Elizabeth M. Pendzick |
| Office | 500 Mamaroneck Ave, Suite 320, Harrison, NY 10528 |
| Phone | (914) 946-3344 |
| Years in Practice | 30+ years |
| Recognitions | Jay Hausman: Super Lawyers 2020–2025 (6 consecutive years) |
| Notable Results | $3.1M (dram shop); $3M (negligent building maintenance) |
| Unique Differentiators | Harrison-based, deep Westchester local presence; dedicated motion and appellate department |
| Languages | English, Spanish |
| Fee Structure | Contingency, free consultation |
What to Look For When Choosing a Car Accident Lawyer in Westchester County
Choosing a personal injury attorney is one of the most consequential decisions you’ll make after a serious accident.
The following ten attributes consistently distinguish strong personal injury representation from mediocre representation.
Specialization in personal injury law. Choose a lawyer who primarily practices personal injury, not a generalist. In New York specifically, look for attorneys with deep experience in no-fault insurance, the serious injury threshold, and pure comparative negligence.
Trial experience and willingness to litigate. Insurance companies offer significantly better settlements when they know the lawyer across the table has actually tried cases. Ask any prospective attorney how many cases they’ve taken to trial.
Contingency fee transparency. Most NY personal injury lawyers charge 33⅓% of the recovery before suit, sometimes rising to 40% if the case goes to trial. Confirm who absorbs case costs if you lose.
Documented case results in similar cases. Look for published settlements and verdicts in cases similar to yours. A firm with strong results in slip-and-fall cases isn’t necessarily strong in rear-end collisions.
Communication and accessibility. How quickly does the firm respond? Will you actually speak with the attorney handling your case, or only with paralegals?
Local court familiarity. A lawyer who regularly practices in Westchester County Supreme Court knows the local judges, procedures, and opposing counsel. That familiarity translates into real strategic advantages.
Resources to front case costs. Complex cases require investment in expert witnesses, accident reconstruction, and medical records. These costs can easily reach tens of thousands of dollars.
Peer reviews and professional recognition. Check Martindale-Hubbell ratings, Super Lawyers selections, Best Lawyers recognition, and Avvo ratings. Verify the attorney’s good standing through the NY State Unified Court System.
Client reviews and testimonials. Read Google reviews, Avvo client reviews, and the firm’s website testimonials. Look for patterns rather than isolated comments.
Free consultation and personal comfort. Nearly every personal injury lawyer in New York offers a free initial consultation. Meet with two or three attorneys before committing.
Watch for red flags. These include guarantees of specific outcomes, pressure to sign a retainer immediately, and vague answers about fees.
A Final Note for Westchester Car Accident Victims
Westchester County sees roughly 20,000 motor vehicle crashes annually. The corridors that generate the most serious accidents include I-287, the Saw Mill River Parkway, the Hutchinson River Parkway, Route 9, and the Cross County Parkway.
The right attorney isn’t just the one with the best marketing. It’s the one whose credentials, track record, and approach align with your specific situation.
Take the time to consult with more than one of the firms profiled above before making a decision. Every firm on this list offers a free consultation.
Kristen Ridley